April 8, 2016 • Philosophy Colloquium: Guido Melchior


Fri, 04/08/2016 - 15:00 to 17:00


The Spring 2016 Philosophy Colloquium Series presents Guido Melchior, University of Graz.  The title of his talk is "Knowing And Checking."  (Abstract below.)

Friday, Apr 8, 2016, 3-5pm, Maloney Seminar Room, Social Sciences 224 (1145 E South Campus Drive 85721).


‘Checking’ is a much neglected concept in contemporary epistemology, although it is a very common concept for describing a subject’s epistemic goals and actions. In this paper, I present an account of checking. I will argue that successfully checking has to be explained in terms that capture the modal features of the involved checking method. Importantly, successfully checking whether p is true requires using a method that is sensitive with respect to p. Thus, sensitivity is necessary for checking, although it is plausibly not necessary for knowing. Hence, sensitivity marks a crucial distinction between knowing and checking. In the first part, I analyze the internalistic and externalistic components of checking which include the intentions of the checking subject plus the modal features of the used checking method. In the second part, I use the distinction between knowing and checking in terms of sensitivity to explain puzzles about knowledge, especially puzzles centering on knowledge closure  like the skeptical puzzle.



Key Word(s) of the Page: 

Send to college calendar: 


Mark as important date: 

College of Social and Behavioral Sciences

Quick Links